With Peter Bondra out the door in Washington, plenty of folks around the league are asking which of the Caps top dollar players will be next to go.
Which leads to this question from the Hockey Ninja:
Eric, you're a big Caps fan. What is your opinion of Gonchar's defensive abilities. We all know the boy can score, but what about in his own end? I've seen him play a tough physical game, but does he sustain that type of play? Also, does he have a tendency to make mental gaffes?
Ah yes, Sergei Gonchar. Whenever anybody asks me about 'Gonch', I'm reminded of something an old friend of mine once said about Slava Fetisov -- that he had the kind of face you'd expect to see working on an oil derrick in Sverdlovsk.
But fear not, we kid because we love. With Gonch, there's a lot to love on the offensive side of the puck, but when it comes to play in his own end, it's admittedly a mixed bag. I'm sure that plenty of folks are scared by the fact that Gonch's plus/minus stands at -19 right now, but you have to look at it in context. One NHL GM, who declined to be named, said that the Capitals defensive situation could be summed up this way: Gonch is a number one, Brendan Witt is a number six, and everybody else belongs in the AHL.
So, essentially, Gonchar is regularly forced to run the power play, play shorthanded, and log extra ice time against top opposition. As a result, he's averaging almost 28 minutes per game, and has been in the top five in the league in this category most of the season. Over the course of a season, getting to -19 when you're essentially one of the few players holding the team together isn't that difficult.
Basically, he's overwhelmed, and trying to make the best of it.
That being said, Gonchar has always played his best all-around game when he was in a regular defensive rotation with five reliable defenseman, and a partner who knew that his role was to stay at home and hold down the fort -- especially when Gonch wants to do some freelancing. His signature play comes on the man advantage, as the puck is being cycled away from him down low on the opposite wing. At times like this, Gonch likes to go back door, darting in from the point as the defense has its back turned.
When it works, it's a great play. But when it doesn't, there better be a defenseman paying attention. For most of his tenure in Washington, that somebody wass either Witt or Ken Klee. And now that Klee is in Toronto, I think that's where Gonchar might fit best. When he knows he's paired with someone responsible, he plays with a lot more confidence. A couple of years back, Klee was regularly near the top of the league in hits (mostly just tying up folks), and I think that was because he was so fixated on taking down his man when Gonchar was cheating a little in the offensive zone.
Which is why I don't think New Jersey would be a great fit for Gonchar. If Scott Stevens weren't injured, I'd pair Gonchar with him in a New York minute. But without Stevens, I don't know who that logical partner would be. My first thought was Colin White, but I've seen him burned and out of position too many times to think that could really work.
One thing I wouldn't ever question is Gonchar's heart. I've seen him bloodied too many times.
UPDATE: The Edmonton Journal has a good roundup of just who's on the trading block in Washington, and what it might take to pry them loose. The article mentions Zach Parise as the sort of player that would get Washington GM George McPhee's attention, but I can't see New Jersey giving him up. Instead, I think a package of players put together by the Leafs might be superior, as McPhee still has major holes on his blue line.